Key takeaways

  • ChatGPT and Gemini named only 15 of 79 agencies in common across 8 cities, and named the same agency first in only 2 of them.
  • Google showed an AI Overview list in only 6 of 10 cities.
  • The most cited sources were directories such as Clutch, The Manifest and GoodFirms, plus the agencies' own websites.
  • Keep directory profiles complete, collect genuine client reviews, and give each city and service a clear page.
  • Check both apps every month with the same questions, and log mentions separately from citations.

What did ChatGPT and Gemini recommend in 10 US cities?

A check run on 5 Nov 2026 asked "best SEO agency in [city]" once per city, on the real ChatGPT app, the real Gemini app, and Google, across ten US metros. The point was not to rank agencies. It was to see how much the three answers overlap when someone asks the exact same local question.

The table below shows what Google's AI Overview displayed and how many agencies both ChatGPT and Gemini named in the same city.